A ghost is still well-fleshed
L ' article "ghost" Ernesto Galli della Loggia - released / not released on the Corriere della Sera of March 2, 2010 - the "ghost" of the PDL, As usual, the central problem, but leaves much to be desired in its description and its analysis.
basic thesis: the PDL is in chaos, in fifteen years was unable to build up its present and was reduced to a "court" on a "sum of quarrelsome rulers' , remnant "Oligarchies and frameworks of the governing parties of the First Republic , populated by people from 'previous doubts, too handsome girls, children and grandchildren, people of every stripe but no capacity' .
causes? The self-centered personality of the leader , alien to modern politics, too rich and too powerful in the media , unable to build even a party of "plastic" and, especially, to address the general crisis of the post-1989 politics. From diagnostic point of view is difficult to disagree with the distinguished political scientist. However, his speech contains dubious argument, and it allows me, even statements "technical" surprising in a scholar of his stature.
First, it gives an opinion on the politics of personal inadequacy and premier that seems as unfounded as ungenerous. Surface, because Berlusconi has been able to properly interpret and know the country and the role of head of government of this country. Ungenerous, because you know that it took to politics after the Eighty with weapons and baggage, with strengths and weaknesses in its possession ... Fifteen years is too long for "Maybe a system "... Maybe ... But what is the model leader austere? The legendary De Gasperi? But we realize that De Gasperi has lived twenty years in the Vatican to study before being co-opted the government and that at the time of his parliamentary experiences in Vienna, Franz Joseph reigned? Or is the ideal Republic?
Silvio Berlusconi has taken the field for the Terga spring up by the judges, as his detractors say the legion of evil, but as an apotheosis h and managed in a spirit of generosity - he could not enjoy his billions antipodes? - And for the sake of the country. With the judges, then, is The opposite happened: if they are pulled on him entering politics. And because of its success has been its have guessed, with great political acumen - as it did with Bossi federalism - the constitutional powers of the arc in the process of liquefaction frustrated aspirations for decades that they were always in the DNA of the majority of 'Italians.
again, accusing him of abuse of media power and financial performance by failing to rivals within his own camp is not only ungenerous, but also wrong, but this we who are the potential leaders alternative? We know what we talk about the talk show and shows the national satirical? Who then is that the bank's internal opponents Knight - what about the 'heretic "Fini? - If not the national average and even Mediaset?
continue, because the criticism of the PDL is extended to the entire center-right? The 'Right' , according to Galli della Loggia, was not capable of saying anything is better than Forza Italy / PDL. Who wrote in 1994 an interview on the right should be aware that right, especially with a capital letter, is something different than the PDL. E then that the phenomenon for more than a look "right", the Northern League can leave something to be desired as a value and planning, but there is no lack of "technical" policy. According to the same opponents, Bossi's party - in addition to "hold" in bioethics - works very well locally and honors which is typically charged. National Alliance has been perhaps a flop in terms of adherence to the project in Fiuggi, but it was not a design right neo-fascist and at times quite respectable. And local leaders and administrators of the AN have not proved as bad as ours suggests.
To influence the condition of imperfect health of the majority party there are also important factors Galli della Loggia, however, fails to mention.
Starting from macroscopic phenomenon - inherent in any political system in contemporary Italy, but particularly evident - the shrinking of the weight of executive power for the benefit of other state powers and the powers of society: the union, the economic and financial power, the average , gl'impalpabili and anonymous "big powers". Today, as the legislative production is coming to unimaginable levels and the judiciary now legislates itself, executive power is harnessed by literally thousands of laws, regulations, rules, procedures, authority, agreements, concerted, tables, the "control room", so that he can not mix much. This weighs particularly when you have the desire, passion and ability to govern: all the things you do wrong to Berlusconi does not recognize, in spite of the doubts expressed about by Galli della Loggia. If, rather than unleash a holy war, to present it as the 'Italian anomaly ", groped to destroy it as the first man and as a politician, it was left to govern decently, perhaps the reported breakdown - The party and the country - would not exist.
The professor also forget that the political class - left to right as: "If Marrazzo" or Bassolino docent - is a mirror of society: a country in "Confetti" and the rule of "slime" can hardly produce a class - hyperbole intended - of "political monks." The vocation of politics as a service only germinates humus in which "serve" is a value and this is certainly not taught to forge self-referentiality and psicolabilità as broadcast-contest for young talents of our television networks. Sure, it's also true that "to understand piscis foetet " and a corrupt ruling class or poor, in a vicious circle, in turn ago a country falling apart.
Finally, not at all convinced by the argument that the crisis of political culture is less strong because it has more body to the left would be the residue of " [...] sixty years of a government of the country so the center and the periphery " and why the center-left " [...] were almost all vertices of political class that was Catholic or Communist, bringing with him the experience and abilities ". Here myopia is likely to prevail. Given that corruption is stagnating everywhere, even in the regions and provinces and municipalities - Bologna docet - "red" and flourishes best where the power bloc is more cohesive and experienced, a political scientist should avoid assigning certificates to anyone positivity, as depended on whether a DNA nobler. And at the same time neglecting the fact that, despite the popular consensus and despite repeated and often large power conquered several times, the ruling class that accuses Galli della Loggia - is a reality kerosene - has had to deal, often succumbing, with the power on intermediate structures that remained in the hands of "hard-core" of the left, Catholic or not, pre-89. And, as we know, the power in an organization such as the modern state, that Moloch is born at the time of Hobbes, lies in the intermediate structures and control: the bureaucracy, in the courts, in government, in the paintings. This power ganglia, on the ribs of the life of the country, was in essence "the same as before." It has "rowed against" With nothing left to offer, it is only expressed in negative terms, using the possibility to block again emerged as that could threaten the balance of the system. If this gluten, this dense blob , compounded by an impediment concentric action of the judiciary, media, political opponents hiding behind dogmatization of the Charter of 1948, as you can not explain the limits, the anxiety that you encounter "Right"? With that sense of history can a liberal liberal as Galli della Loggia attack a person with so much complacency and a project that, mind you, have stopped or at least made more difficult the triumphal march of "joyous war machine" of occhettiana memory? To build
a party, a political class, a class of adequate government or at least be some decent design in harmony with the historical roots of the country, a broad social base and cohesive, a class of men, time and communication tools on the well-timed receptor. The current PDL took part in all this: he has had - and has - brilliant leader, a renovation project that effectively brought together Catholics finally "undemocratic" and right, a social bloc - the middle classes and working classes de-ideologized - not ephemeral. But the rest did not have: the staff necessary political, culture and, of course, whatever people may say, the critical mass of media - including columnists - in favor.
Good politicians are not improvised, it is true. It takes, as mentioned, the "vocations" but those who sow today, when the rule is "mind your own? The school? Better not to open the conversation ... or a sport where the money, the conquest of the "tissue" and blasphemy are the masters?
To bring democracy to contemporary levels of dignity must recreate the nerve centers, revitalize and reconnect elite places of learning, the only people able to set the tone for the entire social body. The Church, from the wonderful lessons on democracy of Pius XII the years 1940 and 1950, several times, at least in terms of principles and values, has made a significant contribution as magisterial as undervalued.
Terms.
At the end of the tight critical we would have expected some indication of how even the slightest move. In reality it is not, and I assume - but I want to be wrong - that, rather than roll up their sleeves, the distinguished scholar who also prefers to wait for a sign from above, nutum of a prince, a nod of the head - or heads of the future.
a class and party politics is built from below, by families and schools, and here the fight is really tough. But there is the alternative - not exclusively - to create a network of processing centers and popular education-oriented and guidance, which is within the reach of many but not all. An example? If nothing else, decide - individuals, associations and bodies - to divert a small part of the flow of money directed to charitable material to the "eminent form of intellectual charity" that is the culture in politics. Mind you: it does not mean you want to ignore the evils of others, but only to say that there is not only physical health. And then, you know, a lot of material costs are triggered by their disorderly conduct and self-injury and for some, reducing wastage due to mismanagement and corruption, there would be a positive bounce back even assistance.
Italy, the Italian right, the politics of the country require this effort: first, because Italy is the center-right, and secondly because there must be a center-right and, third, country - not its traditions policies, so not entirely encouraging - deserves better.
0 comments:
Post a Comment