Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Tea Cup Pomeranian In Louisiana

The "right" to die there


"D IGHT to die with dignity" is a slogan that is heard again now every media pulpit. Who report the facts and circumstances specific book them now, in a seemingly neutral, under this heading. But there is also some - often important and legal experts - the intentionally uses to describe in words "to effect a progressive legal and ethical aspect of ideology, based rights, real or imagined, of man, to indicate the "right" that everyone would have to end their days without waiting for a natural death.
However, even a superficial analysis of the expression leads to ask many questions about the legislative framework, existing or in progress, it configures.

Dying is a right? And why only to die "with dignity"?
If one considers, for each individual self-conscious dying is certainly a possibility. Each of us under certain conditions may opt to end their own lives and can also succeed almost without fail, how many cases of attempted suicide repeated until the "good" ... Kill - as well as kill - or let die is the subject of our freedom. And the range of tools available is directly proportional to the imagination of man ...
But death is also a law? And even before that, what is a right?
According to a classic legal definition of justice, which is consistent with the Recht the Germans and the ius of the Latins, that is the law, " est suum cuique contribute" to give to each his own. The law is therefore something that each has bluntly as "his", which are concerned, that is due. And because of what? That is how we are made for its "nature" and its human essence. So, for being rational and moral creature, or who does not obey a law - however that precedes it - mechanically or fatal, but for their own free will. The
Perhaps death is therefore something of ours, that belongs to us, something that is inherent in our nature to be reasonable and moral? Technically yes. But so is in terms of "ought" of what falls to us anytime, anywhere? Then, without hesitation, no.
The living is not the fruit of our will deliberate: there is "alive" when, at some point in our growth, there is not just instinct that we are something more than a stone or an animal - an insect, a bird, a lizard - which no longer moves
... So is the time of termination "natural" life and the way out of this world are unknown. Now, do not know neither the beginning nor the end of a process in which while we are involved in root tells us that this process is not reasonable in our readiness and, as we are unable to activate nutum, so we can not stop it deliberately.
So either kill or let die it is entirely possible but it's never a right.
Not being a right action to implement their own death or of assisting another person to infliggersela, killing her positively or left to die of starvation or hunger or thirst, is always an illegal act, then in theory always and everywhere illegal.
is elementary to observe - and these short notes are only reflections of a person who is neither giusperito nor philosopher - and resigned really shocked and produces a sharp bitterness to see civil systems exist and operate safely leave organizations, like the note, and sad "Exit." In this regard, it is perhaps not fully understood that the initiatives in favor of euthanasia and assisted suicide on their own or are promoted by a powerful Network International, The World Federation of Right to Die Organizations, founded in 1980, that gathers 38 associations from 23 countries and whose mission is "to defend or protect the right to self-determination of the individual at the end of life " - or whose name is suicide organized and paid - and whose motto is" Defending the choice of a dignified death ". If you do not take into account this basic plot, the acting more discreetly, it is not clear as "cases" apparently spontaneous, as an attempt to end the days of a severely disabled as Eluana but may arise not only to be brought forward to the bitter end with an iron will and refractory to any consideration of the rational and emotional.
This is a seemingly philanthropic attitude, but exudes a revolt in the name of self that is hard to explain, if not evoking hatred for life and, through it, for the Creator, which characterized the ancient currents Gnostic dualism ... And it is curious - but to a certain point - to see how these positions are almost always accompanied by an intransigent opposition to the death penalty. It is right that is conferred on an individual or private third parties the right to kill a person - not only when it is still in utero, but an adult, because sick or just tired of living - more often a weak and innocent, while it denies the principle of legitimate authority, under very strict conditions, the right and duty to punish with death to finally leave the company to be highly dangerous individuals, usually adults and responsible ultimately convicted for serious crimes. It is even more curious, at least, to see that sometimes in the same perspective extends this opposition in the same beautiful jus, right and duty to say that a State has to go to war to defend the community has the cha mission to organize.

As a last remark, though, paradoxically, the right to die a natural death before it existed, because it is accepted by some - there's obviously people who defend the right to suicide, or self-assisted tout court - only provided that it is " for "dignity" with "dignity?
Why do not when it is implemented in a manner "unworthy", in the end and how? And what does "worthy" in this context? Worthy is what befits our status , our objective condition. The term covers a wide range of human properties, worthy what may be inherent to our humanity or our social status or simply to our age group, and so on ... So, how can you determine when and who can establish something - in this case the premature death and voluntary - and a way to leave this world "worthy"? What is the criteria?
The form of death? That is, who is thrown from the seventh floor, or is thrown under a moving train is killed in an "unworthy", while those who cut their veins, or do you practice lethal injection, no? The "worthy" is therefore to avoid the ugliness that the terminal phase of illness c'infligge? Avoid the pain, dirt, humiliation of not being able to dispose of his body and its functions even more elementary?
Or the end? But today there are those who would die because it has become bad, or disappointment in love or for debts or because the dog is dead ... It is not a joke: the modern condition, with solitude and indifference that leads, not infrequently leads personality psychologically fragile, or more often "brittle" to find reasons for things to die in an absolute subordination, in the face of events that would meet with indifference or perhaps raised the laughter of a man or woman of our much more difficult

past ... All these questions seem to me to undermine the meaningfulness of the expression root reported in onset and instead reinforce the notion of existence as datum, as something that is delivered by others, or, at least, our reality but totally unavailable to ourselves and others. A datum that if you read it in light of categories that are not merely natural - which are still more than enough to standardize the behavior of man in society and the society in respect of the individual - becomes donum and unique and valuable opportunity to address not only its natural end, but also to cross "with dignity" - this time so the term makes sense - the threshold of death and going into the "real life" of the soul that has no end. 01/19/2009

0 comments:

Post a Comment